Mr. Probst explains how this challenge is also geared towards creating a bit of antagonism between the survivors. “Helen, I understand that there’s a sea creature trying to eat you. Will this affect anyone’s play during this challenge?”

“Well, I ain’t never seen no sea creature eat a human before,” smiles Clay.

“Me, neither,” says Jan. “How about we eliminate everyone but Helen so she wins immunity so she stays on this island longer so maybe we can watch her get eaten.”

Penny thinks about this, “Ok, but I need to make sure all of you realize that Jake and I are not in an alliance. Yes, I know that I should’ve done this before now because surely everyone will see this as a desperate but completely insincere plea to somehow manipulate everyone to think that I am honest and trustworthy.”

Jake giggles, “Hey, that sure is a good idea, Penny. No one will be at all bothered that you decided to throw me out to the lions only after you realize you have no other choice.”

Jake giggles again and thinks, “I may get to stay here longer than I originally thought.”

And this is just what happened during the “snuff the torch” challenge. Penny went straight for Jake’s jugular and every time someone got a correct answer, they snuffed everyone’s torch but Helen’s.